Civil Litigation

Breached Pre-Sale in Los Cabos: The Buyer's Options

October 11, 2026

In a breached pre-sale in Los Cabos, the useful question is not when you will get the keys, but whether you are better off demanding performance or unwinding the deal. You paid in pre-sale for a condominium unit, the delivery date has passed and the developer keeps asking for more time. What you signed is usually a promissory sale agreement, and the Civil Code for the Free and Sovereign State of Baja California Sur (state) opens two routes for you: demand performance, including the judge signing the deed if the developer refuses, or seek termination, with damages in both cases.

Which one is better is not decided in the abstract. It depends on how the promise is worded, on the agreed penalty, on whether the unit has already been sold to someone else, on whether the development had municipal authorization to be sold and, if you are a foreigner, on the restricted zone trust. This article goes through those pieces in the order in which they weigh on the decision: the contract, the two routes, the penalty, the deadlines, registry protection, authorizations, the procedural code and the routes that run separately.

What you signed: the promise

Everything starts with the paper you signed. Articles 2149 and 2151 of the Civil Code allow parties to bind themselves to enter into a future contract and specify that the promise only creates obligations to act: to enter into the final contract as offered. To be valid it must be in writing, contain the characteristic elements of the final contract and be limited to a certain time (2152). The consequence underpins everything else. Until there is a final contract, the developer owes you a signature, not an apartment, and what you can demand is measured by what the promise says.

That is why it is worth reading with two questions. The first is whether it sets a fixed date to close or ties closing to completion of the works; that answer determines from when the developer is in default. The second is whether it identifies the unit, area, undivided share, price and payment terms, because those are the elements of the contract the judge would have to formalize. The final contract must be executed as a public deed, as articles 2221 and 2222 of the Civil Code require, so a vague promise is a poor starting point for asking that it be signed.

The two civil routes

The right to choose comes from the law. Article 1855 of the Civil Code treats the power to terminate as implied in reciprocal obligations: the injured party chooses between demanding performance or termination, with damages in both cases, and may seek termination if the performance chosen proves impossible. That last rule says something about order. Choosing performance first keeps termination open if performance becomes impossible.

Performance and signing in default

The first route seeks the deed. If the promisor refuses to sign, article 2153 of the Civil Code provides that the judge will sign in the promisor’s default. The exception is decisive: if the property passed for value to a third party in good faith, the promise is left without effect and the promisor is liable for damages. Put in terms of risk, while the unit remains in the developer’s hands, the judge’s signature is a real path; if it has already been sold to a third party in good faith, what remains is a claim for money.

Before betting on this route, two more things are worth knowing: whether the condominium regime has been established by deed and recorded, as article 9 of the Law on the Condominium Property Regime of the State of Baja California Sur (state) requires, and whether the building exists. A judgment ordering a signature does not raise a building.

Termination

The second route unwinds the deal. How much is recovered on termination depends on how the contract characterized each payment and on who breached first; there is no automatic refund. Anyone who expects termination to mean getting back everything paid should first read the clauses on advance payments and penalties. In both routes, the agreed penalty also weighs.

The contractual penalty

Many promises set a penalty for delay, and the penalty changes the math. Under article 1745 of the Civil Code, if a penalty was agreed, damages cannot be claimed in addition. To collect it, the creditor does not have to prove harm (1747), and the penalty cannot exceed the value or amount of the principal obligation (1748). The penalty is, then, a shortcut with a ceiling. It saves you from proving how much you lost, but it fixes how much you collect on that account even if the real harm was greater.

Penalty and performance can only be demanded together if the penalty was agreed for mere delay or for performance different from what was agreed (1751). If your promise set it for delay, you can seek performance and the penalty at the same time; if it set it for the breach itself, you will have to choose one or the other. Once you decide what to ask for, the question of when remains.

Deadlines to act

Time runs. Outside the exceptional cases, article 1164 of the Civil Code sets ten years, from when the obligation became enforceable, for the right to demand performance to lapse. When it starts running depends on the promise, and here it matters again whether it set a fixed date or tied it to the works.

If the unit is delivered with defects, the deadlines are different and much shorter. Articles 2048 and 2050 of the Civil Code require the transferor to answer for hidden defects and allow the buyer to seek rescission or a price reduction; those actions lapse after two years for real property, counted from delivery (2055).

The condominium law has its own clock. Its article 30, section II, makes the original owners of new units liable for hidden construction defects, with actions that lapse one year after delivery. Its article 9, section IX, provides that, where there are promises to sell units, the founding deed must state the bond the original owners must post to answer for the construction and its defects. Neither law says how their deadlines fit together for a new unit; which one governs the specific action is reviewed with the contract and the delivery date. Until that is clear, the prudent course is to count on the shorter one.

Protecting the unit during the lawsuit

The annotation in the Registry is the key. Article 2953, section III, of the Civil Code allows a lawsuit seeking performance of a preliminary contract to be preventively annotated in the Public Property Registry when it concerns real property or rights in rem. The annotation binds any later acquirer (2954), and the annotated property may be sold, but without prejudice to whoever obtained the annotation (2955). This is the piece to weigh against the exception to signing in default: if the developer sells the unit after the lawsuit is annotated, the annotation binds whoever buys it and the sale is made without prejudice to whoever obtained the annotation.

The annotation has a horizon. Under article 2945, it lapses after three years and may be extended for two years at a time, if the extension is recorded before it lapses. A lawsuit that drags on without anyone watching that date can lose the protection that justified it. If what was promised is trust beneficiary rights, you need to assess whether that section applies. And before choosing a route, it is worth looking at the development’s administrative foundations.

If the development was sold without authorization

Sales advertising requires municipal authorization. Article 77 BIS of the Urban Development Law for the State of Baja California Sur (state) requires prior authorization from the town council for sales advertising and, for condominiums, 80% progress on the phase being sold, which may be replaced by an additional guarantee in favor of the town council; the advertising must cite the municipal resolution authorizing the works and the authorization of the advertising. The rule gives you a concrete test to run: if the brochure or ad you were sold with does not cite those resolutions, you already have a first sign that the rule was not met.

Article 75 of that law declares acts arising from the construction of condominiums carried out without the corresponding authorization or in risk zones affected by absolute or relative nullity. It does not specify whether the promise signed with the buyer is one of those acts or with what effects; that is analyzed with the contract and the development’s authorization file. It is an open question, and strategy should not be built on an answer the law does not give. If you are a foreigner, there is also a prior question: what were you promised.

Foreign buyer: what was promised

What was promised may not be ownership. Los Cabos borders the Pacific Ocean and the Gulf of California, under article 120 of the Political Constitution of the Free and Sovereign State of Baja California Sur, and the restricted zone covers a strip of fifty kilometers along the beaches, under article 2, section VI, of the Foreign Investment Law (federal).

If the unit is in that strip, article 11 of that law provides that a credit institution, with a permit from the Secretaría de Relaciones Exteriores, acquires rights over the property as trustee and the foreigner is the beneficiary. What was promised is then trust beneficiary rights, and you should check who the trustee is and who must sign. With the what settled, the where remains.

Procedural code and a possible commercial route

The procedural code is in transition. The National Code of Civil and Family Procedure (national) enters into force in each state according to the declaration of its legislature and, absent one, automatically no later than April 1, 2027, under its second transitory article. As of October 8, 2026 no declaration for Baja California Sur had been published in the Official Bulletin of the State Government, so civil lawsuits in Los Cabos are currently handled under the Code of Civil Procedure for the State of Baja California Sur (state).

If the developer is a merchant, the commercial route may be raised. Article 75, section II, of the Commercial Code (federal) treats purchases and sales of real property for commercial speculation as commercial acts, and article 1050 of the Commercial Code subjects to commercial law an act that is commercial for one party and civil for the other. The promise only binds the parties to enter into the final contract and article 75 does not mention it; in case of doubt, that same article provides that the commercial nature of the act “shall be set by judicial discretion.” The route, therefore, is a decision made before suing and with arguments, not a formality. What remains is to measure PROFECO, the federal consumer protection agency: what it can and cannot do.

PROFECO: scope and limits

PROFECO’s door is narrow. Under article 73 of the Federal Consumer Protection Law (federal), that law governs acts concerning real property only when the provider is a subdivider, builder or promoter in the public sale of housing intended as a dwelling; if the unit was bought for vacation rental, the fit is debatable.

Within that door there are concrete obligations. Article 73 Bis requires, in pre-sale, showing the executive project, the model and the building authorizations; article 74, delivery within the agreed period and with the specifications offered. PROFECO conciliates and may issue an opinion that will be an enforceable title only if the judge considers the obligation certain, due and liquidated, and the provider may challenge it (114). Without conciliation or accepted arbitration, rights are preserved (116). Outside arbitration it does not declare termination or award damages; that belongs to the courts. A complaint can open a negotiation, but it does not replace the lawsuit. There is a third route, which runs separately.

The criminal route runs separately

Fraud is another file. Article 241 of the Criminal Code for the Free and Sovereign State of Baja California Sur (state) punishes as specific fraud, among others, transferring for value something one has no right to dispose of after receiving the price, in section I; selling the same thing to two people, in section III; and transferring units in a condominium built in non urbanizable or risk zones while concealing it from the buyer, in section XXIII. Under article 243, those cases are prosecuted on complaint by the victim. A construction delay is not fraud in itself, and a criminal complaint does not replace the civil action.

Frequently asked questions

Can the judge sign the deed if the developer refuses?

Yes. If the promisor refuses to sign, the judge signs in the promisor’s default. The exception is if the unit passed for value to a third party in good faith: then the promise is left without effect and the developer is liable for damages.

If I terminate the contract, do I get back everything I paid?

There is no automatic refund. How much is recovered depends on how the contract characterized each payment, on who breached first and on the agreed penalty.

Can I collect the penalty and damages on top?

No. If a penalty was agreed, damages cannot be claimed in addition, although they need not be proven to collect it. Penalty and performance can only be demanded together if the penalty was agreed for mere delay or for performance different from what was agreed.

How do I protect the unit while the lawsuit lasts?

With the preventive annotation of the lawsuit in the Public Property Registry, which binds any later acquirer: the unit may be sold, but without prejudice to whoever obtained the annotation. It lapses after three years and may be extended for two years at a time if the extension is recorded before it lapses.

Can PROFECO rescind my contract?

Outside arbitration, it does not declare termination or award damages. It conciliates and may issue an opinion, and its law only reaches the public sale of housing intended as a dwelling.

How to start

Gather the file: the promise with its annexes and plans, proof of payment, the advertising you received, the notices about delays and photographs of construction progress. Gathering them is not enough to file or win a case, but it allows it to be assessed. Do not send identification or banking details in the first contact. With those papers on the table, the decision comes back to you: performance or termination, with the penalty, the deadlines, the annotation and the development’s authorization already measured. That is the difference between a bet and a calculation, and it is the analysis we do in our real estate litigation practice.

If your case matches what is described here, you can request a complimentary initial assessment, subject to scope review. Contact does not create an attorney client relationship until the engagement is formalized in writing.

IBG Legal, headquartered in Cancún with an office in Mexico City, advises buyers and investors on real estate transactions and litigation, and handles matters in Los Cabos.

IBG Legal, your legal ally in Mexico. For any question about your investment or your property, contact us.

Sources and references

  • Civil Code for the Free and Sovereign State of Baja California Sur (state), articles 1164, 1745, 1747, 1748, 1751, 1855, 2048, 2050, 2055, 2149, 2151, 2152, 2153, 2221, 2222, 2945, 2953, 2954 and 2955. Latest amendment: Official Bulletin of the State Government, September 8, 2026, per the State Congress compilation.
  • Law on the Condominium Property Regime of the State of Baja California Sur (state), articles 9, section IX, and 30, section II. Latest amendment: Official Bulletin of the State Government, October 31, 2016, per the State Congress compilation.
  • Urban Development Law for the State of Baja California Sur (state), articles 75 and 77 BIS. Latest amendment: Official Bulletin of the State Government, November 21, 2025, per the State Congress compilation.
  • Political Constitution of the Free and Sovereign State of Baja California Sur (state), article 120. Latest amendment: Official Bulletin of the State Government, September 8, 2026, per the State Congress compilation.
  • Criminal Code for the Free and Sovereign State of Baja California Sur (state), articles 241, sections I, III and XXIII, and 243. Latest amendment: Official Bulletin of the State Government, September 8, 2026, per the State Congress compilation.
  • Code of Civil Procedure for the State of Baja California Sur (state). Latest amendment: Official Bulletin of the State Government, April 30, 2025, per the State Congress compilation.
  • National Code of Civil and Family Procedure (national), second transitory article of the decree published in the Official Gazette of the Federation on June 7, 2023. Latest amendment: Official Gazette of the Federation, January 15, 2026.
  • Official Bulletin of the State Government of Baja California Sur (state), indexes of the issues published from January 7 to October 8, 2026, and the State Congress List of Decrees for 2024, 2025 and 2026 (consulted October 9, 2026): no declaration of the National Code for the state.
  • Commercial Code (federal), articles 75, section II and last paragraph, and 1050. Latest amendment: Official Gazette of the Federation, November 14, 2025.
  • Federal Consumer Protection Law (federal), articles 73, 73 Bis, 74, 114 and 116. Latest amendment: Official Gazette of the Federation, December 12, 2025.
  • Foreign Investment Law (federal), articles 2, section VI, and 11. Latest amendment: Official Gazette of the Federation, May 27, 2024.
  • The latest amendment dates of the state laws come from the compilations of the Congress of the State of Baja California Sur, which do not replace the official edition of the Official Bulletin of the State Government.
Civil Litigation

Discuss this matter

This article is for informational purposes only and does not imply that IBG Legal accepts matters outside its core practice areas.

Chat on WhatsApp
Schedule a consultation WhatsApp